This may depend somewhat on how dry you expect to be and what material your cockpit rim is made of. Kayaking is a watersport. Even with a skirt from the Gods, over time water will find its way into your boat. That's why million dollar yachts come equipped with a bilge pump. But if your expectation is to remain reasonably dry after numerous low braces or Eskimo rolls, we recommend a sprayskirt made with neoprene. If your kayak rim is made from a composite material such as fiberglass, Kevlar, wood, or thermoformed plastic other than polyethylene, a nylon fabric skirt might be acceptable although you'll be having to dump water more often than when using a neoprene skirt.